close up of Classic Southern Potato Salad recipe

Classic Southern Potato Salad

 

Make Classic Southern Potato Salad and never give too much thought again about what to bring to a potluck dinner or a friend’s cookout.

Potato salad is serious business in the South and this straightforward potato salad recipe is a crowd pleasing classic that pairs nicely with just about any grill item it goes up against, from barbecue to burgers, steak, chicken or ribs! This is a classic southern potato salad with eggs.

Pinterest pin image for Classic Southern Potato salad recipe

This traditional potato salad recipe plates brilliantly with my

Oven Baked Deep South Barbecue Ribs

Perfectly Perfect Grilled Chicken Drumsticks

or a superbly Marinated Steak from your grill.

Gatherings here in the South do not happen without a big bowl of homemade potato Salad.

March, April, June, and July are cookout months down here, and this summer, I would guess I have prepared the salad at least six times. If you remember your mother cooking a dressing as part of her potato salad ingredients, you may want to try my recipe for A Hearty Penna Dutch Potato Salad.

While potato salad may not necessarily be ‘southern’ in origin, to too many people it remains valid that Southerners have taken a reasonably good dish, booted up the ‘element of spunk,’ and declared the fresh adaptation a Southern classic. Potato salad reminds me of my Grandfather. Gramps was that one member of our family who wore the badge of “Absolute Potato Salad Maker.” This recipe is basically his, as best I remember it.

Nothing fancy or extravagant, just potatoes, eggs, good mayonnaise, onion, celery, a little bit of yellow or Dijon mustard, some pickle relish, salt, and pepper.  A simple, basic, satisfying dish that is full of flavor and texture. It is truly the ideal accompaniment to a juicy burger hot off the grill. His was the ‘potato salad among potato salads.’ I of course thought it was the best potato salad.

crock of potato salad
 

Classic Southern Potato Salad is an easy potato salad recipe. It yields a delicious sequence of potatoes, hard boiled eggs, sweet onions, celery, pickle relish, mayonnaise, yellow mustard, and seasoning. This classic potato salad is perfect for potlucks, cookouts, and picnics. I would challenge you to find traditional potato salad recipe or a southern potato salad recipe without eggs, but you can omit them in this recipe if you do not want them.

So, “Absolute Potato Salad Maker” is a highly coveted title. After my Grandfather passed away, I never tasted potato salad like his. I promise you, every family vacation that we would pile in the station wagon and motor on down to Myrtle Beach to visit with my grandparents (we lived in New Jersey, then), my Mom would make the call ahead and request Gramp’s potato salad for me. Once we got there, it was sometimes the ONLY thing I would eat despite my Grandmother cooking up a horde of food on account of our visit. My Mom and my cousin Holly both come close to his. But I like to think I was the major consumer of his potato technique, and as good as Mom and Holly’s salads are, they are not quite Gramp’s.

crock of potato salad

Try these additional fabulous salads, including

Mothership Tomato Salad 

Creamy Southern Coleslaw

Fresh Corn & Tomato Salad

Cucumber Chopped Salad with Feta & Pine Nuts

I guess that the badge of ‘Absolute Potato Salad Maker’ is somebody who has spent years in the kitchen and is respected for their ability to cook well. Despite being an okay cook and a now food blogger, it would not be until last year at about this time, that I gave his potato salad a shot. HA! Now, if I were honest and told you how many times I tried (and epically failed) to recreate this potato salad, you would never believe me.

Yet, and for what felt like the hundredth time, my Mom and I tackled potato salad…again. But, to make you understand, we are not trying to just make any potato salad, we were trying to make Grandpa’s potato salad. No celery seed or apple cider vinegar was lending the right flavor to this. And while mayonnaise counts, we found for us it was not going to be Miracle Whip. Low and behold, we made potato salad that makes us think we are there…a southern style potato salad.

crock of potato salad

What Is The Best Potato to Use in Potato Salad?

Not all potatoes are created equal when it comes to making this style potato salad. Do not use red potatoes. Use starchy potatoes that get a little bit soft when you cook them. Russet potatoes have a higher starch content, which makes them fluffier than other varieties of potatoes. A waxy potato such as a red potato will not do for this southern favorite. I use russet potatoes almost exclusively for this recipe. They yield a mealy texture and they also break down well. Yukon Gold potatoes would be my second choice. And since this method specifies a portion of the cooked potatoes be mashed, russets are the easiest to run through a ricer to achieve this.

This cool, creamy, and slightly sweet dressing cloaks tender potatoes and crunchy onions and celery in this virtuoso Classic Southern Potato Salad. This is a no-cook dressing, a contrast to my wildly popular Hearty Penna Dutch Potato Salad.

 

close up of Classic Southern Potato Salad recipe

How To Make Potato Salad?

Potato salad also depends on perfectly cooked and seasoned potatoes. The best potato salad recipes have a secret step in the method. Most of you probably add salt to your boiling water, but do you add sugar? This is key. Forget about ‘skin-on’ and peel and dice the potatoes before boiling them. This allows the salt and sugar in the water to absorb well. You will have effectively seasoned your base. Also, hard-boil the eggs ahead of time. Popped into the refrigerator for two or more hours gives them ample time to cool down entirely before cutting. Mom always says to do this no matter what you are putting eggs into, so it was automatic for me. Potato salad recipes with eggs were not as common up north. A potato salad recipe was just that, potatoes.

Some recipes call for either dill pickle relish or sweet pickle relish, or a combination. I usually add a little dill relish and a lot of sweet relish. My ratio is 3:1, but taste after mixing so you can get your salad exactly the way you will like it. Lastly, I like a combination of both mash and chunk, so I rice about 1/3 of the cooked potatoes while they are hot and stir them together with the chunks. If you do not have a ricer, you can use a basic potato masher or run the cooked potato through the openings on a colander. You are not “mashing,” rather breaking apart into the smallest bitty bits. Think fluffy and airy. While you need to allow time for this salad to chill before serving, it’s a straightforward, easy method incorporating just a handful of basic ingredients.

crock of potato salad

All images and text ©Jenny DeRemer for Not Entirely Average, LLC

crock of potato salad

Classic Southern Potato Salad

Potato salad is serious business in the South. Make Classic Southern Potato Salad and never give too much thought again about what to bring to a potluck dinner or a friend’s cookout.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe Rate Recipe
Prep Time: 25 minutes
Cook Time: 25 minutes
Chill: 2 hours
Total Time: 2 hours 50 minutes
Course: Side Dish
Cuisine: American
Keyword: barbecue, barbecue side dish, bbq, cookout, eggs, grill, no-cook dressing, potato, potato salad, side dish
Servings: 16 servings, 1/2 cup serving
Calories: 107kcal

Want a bigger or smaller serving size? Hover over the serving size and move the bar until you get the number of servings you want. Easy.

Equipment

  • ricer or potato masher

Ingredients

Did you know that it’s super easy to print out a version of a half recipe or even a double recipe on Not Entirely Average? Hover over the serving size (highlighted in blue, it says 24 on this recipe) and then slide the the white line to the left to make less or to the right to make more. This "calculator" allows you to play until you get the number of servings you want. Easy. 

    for boiling the potatoes

    • 1/4 cup salt
    • 1/4 cup granulated sugar

    Ingredients for Classic Southern Potato Salad

    • 4 eggs hard boiled and well chilled
    • 2 pounds russet potatoes peeled, diced, and boiled until fork tender
    • 1/2 cup red onion diced
    • 1/2 cup celery diced (I try to use celery with leaves)
    • 2 ounces diced pimentos
    • 3/8 cup sweet relish
    • 1/4 cup dill relish
    • 1 tablespoon yellow mustard or Dijon mustard
    • 1/2 cup mayonnaise
    • 1 tablespoon sugar
    • salt and pepper to taste
    • celery leaves
    • paprika

    Instructions

    The Method

    • In a medium bowl, whisk the mayonnaise, yellow or Dijon mustard, and 1 tablespoon of granulated sugar well. Set aside.
    • Scrub potatoes well and peel. Dice the potatoes into 1 inch chunks.
    • Place diced potatoes into a large stock pot with enough water to cover them. Add 1/4 cup salt and 1/4 cup granulated sugar to the water and boil until you can easily poke into the potatoes with a fork or pairing knife.
    • Drain potatoes into a colander. Using a slotted spoon, scoop out about 1/3 of the potatoes and pass through a ricer. If you do not have a ricer, use a potato masher and gently break up the potatoes. You want fluffy versus mashed.
    • In a large bowl, combine all of the potatoes, chopped boiled eggs, diced onion, celery, and pimentos. Add the relishes.
    • Pour the dressing over the potato mixture and using a rubber spatula, mix the entire bowl of ingredients until very well combined, making sure to scrape down the sides of the bowl. Add salt and pepper to taste. Add additional relish if necessary after tasting.
    • Cover with plastic and refrigerate for a minimum of 2 hours. Stir well before serving. Dust with chopped celery leaves and paprika if desired.

    Nutrition

    Serving: 1serving | Calories: 107kcal | Carbohydrates: 19g | Protein: 3g | Fat: 3g | Saturated Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 42mg | Sodium: 1941mg | Potassium: 276mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 7g | Vitamin A: 249IU | Vitamin C: 7mg | Calcium: 17mg | Iron: 1mg

    Please note that the nutrition information provided above is approximate and meant as a guideline only.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published.

    Recipe Rating




    2 Comments

    1. Your recipe right here is SO close to what I make! LOVE IT!!! My potatoes end up being over cooked a smidge giving me the combined texture. A happy accident I guess.
      I enjoy visiting your site and Happy 4th of July!5 stars

      1. Penny, I LOVE happy accidents! You and I would probably enjoy much of the same types of recipes given texture is a consideration for us both. Let me know if there is something specific you’d like to see on Not Entirely Average. I just may have the recipe idea sitting in a pile and need to be nudged! Happy and SAFE 4th Penny! x – Jenny