An Egg Soufflé Recipe with Autumn Herbs

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure policy.

Fresh ingredients lend subtle nuances to this beautiful beginner Egg Soufflé Recipe with Autumn Herbs, ready from oven to table in under an hour!

This Recipe is Modified from The Pleasures of Cooking for One to yield additional servings in memory of Judith Jones, whom the world lost in August of 2017 and presented the limitless possibilities for pleasure and experimentation when cooking only for ourselves.

Too many novice home chefs fear the soufflé. I am here to tell you that they aren’t half as tricky as they are made out to be.

Soufflés have two main components: a base that will become the flavor profile and silky beaten egg whites. The method for almost all soufflés is making a base, folding in whipped egg whites, and baking.

If you’re preparing a sweet dessert soufflé, maybe your base is caramel or chocolate. If you’re assembling a savory soufflé, maybe it is a cheese or herb base. In either case, the technique for almost all soufflé recipes is essentially the same.

This savory (or sweet!) baked egg-based dish originating in France relies on the correct consistency of its base, stiff egg whites, and the careful folding of the base and the beaten whites together JUST before the baking. The egg whites are, by far, the most essential ingredient in a soufflé. So, it’s vital to get the whites correct.

But it’s also important to complete everything else in the method before you begin whipping your whites. This is so that once those whites are ready, the base can immediately be combined, no waiting!

Ingredients for An Egg Soufflé Recipe with Autumn Herbs

• butter, salted or unsalted
• grated Parmesan cheese; use FRESH – NOT the the green can!
• all-purpose flour
• milk
• paprika
• Kosher salt
• eggs
• fresh nutmeg
• fresh herbs such as thyme, sage, rosemary, oregano, or chives

How This Recipe Came About…

My dear friend Moe gifted me what has become one of my most used cookbooks. The Pleasures of Cooking for One by the late Judith Jones explores the primitive art, preparation, and pure enjoyment of food. It also explores the human mind.

Judith’s knack for focusing on self-care and emotional preservation through the art and assembly of straightforward classical dishes is fascinating. Her opinion? Cooking for yourself is an exercise in spiritual upholding.

Food preparation is treating yourself. It’s giving yourself permission to be bold and go great. Create something that you will love, and that will love you back. Food is your incredible gift to yourself, so relish the process of creating beautiful dishes for yourself as much as you will surely enjoy the result.

Judith’s Cheese Soufflé was among the first recipes I attempted from the book. This was WAY BEFORE I even knew I enjoyed cooking. This cookbook is part of my journey to where I am today with Not Entirely Average.

I have thought A LOT about Judith Jones over the years. She is best known as a writer and editor for having rescued The Diary of Anne Frank from the reject pile. She also championed Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking. And if those two MONUMENTAL achievements are not enough, she is a twice James Beard Foundation award recipient.

Judith’s Cheese Soufflé is one of my favorite weeknight dinners. Paired with a table wine and a basic salad, dinner is on my table in under 30 minutes. I have reimagined her original method for a larger yield. The recipe I share today is adapted from Judith’s original but serves 4 to 6 as a main dish and boasts the addition of fresh herbs and fresh nutmeg.

What Is a Substitute for Freshly Grated Parmesan or Cheddar in This Recipe?

To be clear, we are talking about 2 to 3 tablespoons of cheese to “flour” the buttered soufflé dish and a wee handful more to compliment the herbs in flavoring the egg base. So, you do not need very much when considering what to purchase.

Also, remember that when we talk about Parmesan cheese ANYWHERE on Not Entirely Average, we are discussing real cheese. We are never discussing anything shaken from a can. No processed cheese food either. ONLY REAL CHEESE.

There are many possibilities for subbing out the Parmesan and the cheddar. I do this very often because I like so many hard cheeses better than Parmesan. I will confess, however, that I LOVE the cheddar in this soufflé.

You may use one type of cheese or two throughout the recipe, as noted in the recipe card.

Beaufort cheese is an Alpine cheese produced in Beaufortain, Tarentaise Valley, and Maurienne in the French Alps. It is a firm, raw cow’s milk cheese associated with the gruyere family. Run over the blade of a micro plane, this cheese has distinctive buttery, nutty, and mildly salty nuances. There is nothing about Beaufort cheese that is not to love.

Beemster is a hard Dutch cow’s milk cheese whose aging process resembles other hard cheeses like Gouda. I cannot get enough of Beemster. When I can find it, I purchase and keep a block in my chiller. Even the tough rind becomes useful for flavoring soups, so nothing is ever wasted with this superior cheese. Beemster is a cheese I will almost always purchase before any other.

Comté is a French cheese produced in the Jura Massif region of Eastern France; this unpasteurized cow’s milk hard mountain cheese is matured in caves, establishing its unique taste, texture, and color. I always use Comté as a substitute for cheese in and on pasta dishes.

What Is the Best Way to Make a Soufflé?

Read your recipe…TWICE! Once you begin a soufflé recipe, time is precious. Speed is mildly integral. Your soufflé won’t be successful if you continuously stop mid-recipe to search for or measure an ingredient.

Measure all the ingredients before you start cooking. I arrange my elements in the order I will use them. This helps me to move seamlessly.

Ensure all your ingredients, especially the eggs, are at room temperature. Do not use cold eggs. Yes, this IS a thing. Do not use cold eggs…

Here is a quick lesson on cracking those eggs…YES, I AM SERIOUS! Why? Breaking eggs on any edge, for example, the edge of a bowl or the edge of a countertop, hosts a greater probability of you compromising that egg’s yolk. So…crack the eggs by tapping them on a FLAT SURFACE such as your countertop.

Separate the egg whites from the egg yolks by allowing the egg whites to slip through your fingers into a bowl gently. Don’t let any bit of yolk into the whites, which will compromise the ability of the egg whites to trap air and do their job for ‘the puff.’

How To Make an Egg Soufflé?

Determine what fresh herbs you will use for your soufflé. Fall herbs are at the end of their growth cycle.

Collect the young green tips as opposed to woody bottom stems. The tender, newer leaves will suit much better than older, possibly bitter leaves.

Consider rosemary, thyme, chives, sage, and oregano. Selecting one herb and not a combination usually works best. And remember, leaves only. No stems.

A baked egg souffle does require another critical step to ensure its success: MUST PREHEAT OVEN! Now that you’ve done all the work to ensure a perfect and fluffy egg soufflé do not skip ahead by popping the casserole dish with the fragile egg mixture into a cold or lukewarm oven.

If fresh herbs are unavailable, dried herbs may be used per a 3:1 ratio; for example, three teaspoons of fresh herbs to 1 teaspoon dried.

The oven MUST BE PREHEATED before the baking dish is loaded in. Once the soufflé is finished, carefully pull it from the oven and serve immediately.

No matter what, ALWAYS make the soufflé base first. Whether the soufflé you are perfecting is savory or sweet, always combine the egg yolks with the base ingredients so they are ready to marry the whites as soon as they transform into stiff peaks.

• 

• 

Combining the egg mixture base with the egg whites is way beyond the capability of your fabulously bulging biceps. Trust me. For this step, bust out the electric hand mixer or your stand mixer fitted with the whip attachment. Always beat the whites on medium speed.

This is not a fast process. You are going for fluffy here. Initially, you’ll get soft peaks. Keep mixing until stiff peaks form. Stiff peaks are defined as pulling the mixer away, and the peaks of those egg whites remain stiff and standing. You must beat a bit longer if peaks form and wilt slightly or collapse. NOTE: A food processor will NOT work for this.

Fold the egg whites into the egg yolk mixture in three stages. Just in case today is an iffy math day for you, this means one-third, one-third, and one-third 🙂 The peaks of the freshly whipped egg whites will start to lose their stability immediately after you’ve achieved those stiff peaks. Because of this, you must begin the folding process in stages immediately.

To the base batter, add one-third of the egg whites. Using a rubber spatula, run under the batter, scraping the bottom of the bowl while folding the batter up and over onto the whites. Turn the bowl 1/4 turn clockwise. Repeat.

Continue after each fold, turning 1/4 turn clockwise until the whites are no longer streaky in the batter. Do this twice more using the remaining two-thirds of the whites until mostly all streaks are gone.

Modifying The Norm to Make It Not Entirely Average…

I often go out of my way to make an otherwise splendid soufflé not entirely average by seeking a unique hard cheese with a unique flavor for “flouring” my soufflé dish. If I find a cheese I enjoy, I add it to my recipe card in my recipe box for the next time. It is like giving myself a little recipe rating with the cheese I like best.

I also grab shallots for a caramelized shallot and herb combination. Sage pairs well with caramelized shallot and incorporating these two flavors alone is a savory dish enjoyed as a side to roast lamb.

For a heartier soufflé, mashed potatoes combined with aged cheddar cheese and rosemary leaves are distinctive if you want to offer a dinner and a breakfast; an easy egg soufflé with spinach or an egg and cheese soufflé with spinach and Gruyere cheese are great bases to consider.

Is An Egg Soufflé a Main Dish or A Side?

The healthy egg soufflé recipe I share today may be either a main dish or a side. It is a lighter version of a soufflé, making it a good choice for a breakfast souffle.

If serving as a main, this recipe will feed four to six. I recommend a salad along with a crusty bread and good table wine.

If serving as a side dish, consider serving it alongside my Herb Crusted Pork with Zinfandel Reduction, as this dish is perfect for this mild-flavored herb soufflé.

Breakfast souffles need no more than a fresh fruit option, such as an apple fruit salad with yogurt parfait, and a myriad of home-baked breads such as a savory spinach and feta loaf, banana bread, or a slice of subtly tangy buttermilk bread. Cut the breads into smaller pieces and arrange them in many baskets for eaters to select from a table array.

With an exciting selection of sides, a breakfast soufflé can stretch to serve 10 to 12 people with slightly smaller servings. If unsure you’ll have enough, always bake two to ensure second helpings.

How Long Does It Take To Bake An Egg Soufflé?

Plan on a 25-ish minute cook time. This bake MUST be UNDISTURBED—no opening the oven and peeking.

How Do You Know When An Egg Soufflé Is Done?

To know if your egg soufflé is done to perfection on the inside, giggle it gently. If it barely moves in the middle, it is done.

Can I Freeze An Egg Soufflé?

I know many out there will say that freezing a soufflé is possible, and it is. But…freezing brings with it so many unfortunate consequences. I do not advise freezing. Chief among my reasons is that thawing and re-heat all or a portion of a previously baked soufflé will not yield that characteristic ‘puff’ that soufflés are best known for. I also find the density changes and alters the flavors in the bake.

How To Serve an Egg Soufflé?

Hot and straight from your oven. When serving an egg souffle for guests, have them gathered around the table so they can see how beautiful it is.