The Keeper Recipes We Kept Making

This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy + disclosures for details.

These are the recipes we couldn’t wait to try the first time — and now, they’re the dishes we cannot wait to make again! From the cozy, cheesy comfort of Broccoli Cheddar Potato Pierogi and crispy Fully Loaded Potato Skins with Chipotle Southwest Guacamole to the sweet indulgence of Coconut Cream Pie French Toast and Apple Cheddar Pie, each recipe brings joy back to the table. Whether it’s the vibrant zing of Greek Potato Salad or the hearty warmth of Sheet Pan Salmon with Potatoes and Chickpeas, these are the favorites that kept our kitchen testers coming back for more, meal after meal.

Broccoli Cheddar Potato Pierogi

overhead photo of Broccoli Cheddar Potato Pierogi
Photo credit: Half Baked Harvest

These Broccoli Cheddar Potato Pierogi are a fun cross between creamy broccoli cheddar soup and cheesy potato pierogi. They’re warm, cozy, and perfect for a cold winter’s night. This recipe is sure to be a family favorite.
Get the Recipe: Broccoli Cheddar Potato Pierogi

Coconut Yogurt Waffles (Vegan + GF)

Homemade Vegan GF Yogurt Waffles that are both crispy and tender
Photo credit: Minimalist Baker

These Coconut Yogurt Waffles are vegan, gluten-free, and ready in under 30 minutes! Made with simple ingredients like almond milk, coconut yogurt, and gluten-free flour, they’re perfect for a quick and delicious breakfast. Top them with fresh fruit, berry compote, or coconut whipped cream for an extra treat.
Get the Recipe: Coconut Yogurt Waffles (Vegan + GF)

Coconut Cream Pie French Toast

Plates with slices of Coconut Cream Pie French Toast
Photo credit: Minimalist Baker

This Coconut Cream Pie French Toast recipe is a decadent breakfast or dessert that’s surprisingly easy to make with just 10 ingredients. Using coconut milk and vegan butter, this dairy-free and refined sugar-free dish brings a tropical twist to classic comfort food. Top it off with coconut whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes for the ultimate treat!
Get the Recipe: Coconut Cream Pie French Toast

Greek Potato Salad

Greek Potato Salad foodiecrush.com
Photo credit: Foodie Crush

This Greek potato salad is a vibrant twist on the classic, featuring sun-dried tomatoes, olives, and feta for a burst of Mediterranean flavor. Dressed with a zesty Greek dressing, it’s a perfect side dish for potlucks, picnics, or a light lunch.
Get the Recipe: Greek Potato Salad

Apple Cheddar Pie

apple pie with cheddar cheese crust
Photo credit: Sally’s Baking Recipes

Looking for a unique twist on a classic fall dessert? This Apple Cheddar Pie features a cheddar cheese crust that perfectly complements the sweet cinnamon apple filling. It’s a delightful and unexpected upgrade from traditional apple pie that’s sure to impress!
Get the Recipe: Apple Cheddar Pie

Cilantro Lime Rice

Cilantro Lime Rice
Photo credit: Love and Lemons

Skip the trip to Chipotle and make this easy cilantro lime rice at home! This recipe is fresh, flavorful, and perfect as a side dish or base for burrito bowls. Plus, it’s dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian-friendly!
Get the Recipe: Cilantro Lime Rice

Light Creamy Potato Salad

Light and creamy potato salad recipe with quick pickled cucumbers, fresh dill, and yogurt dressing in a white bowl.
Photo credit: Feasting at Home

This light and creamy potato salad is a fresh twist on a classic! Quick pickled cucumbers, fresh dill, and a lightened-up yogurt dressing make this potato salad recipe perfect for any occasion.
Get the Recipe: Light Creamy Potato Salad

Authentic Birria

birria.
Photo credit: The Big Man’s World

Craving authentic Mexican flavors? This Birria recipe delivers! Enjoy it as a hearty stew, or shred the tender beef to make delicious tacos and quesadillas.
Get the Recipe: Authentic Birria

Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes

Presenting a delicious Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes
Photo credit: Two Peas and Their Pod

These Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes are a vegetarian family favorite! Baked sweet potatoes are filled with black beans, veggies, enchilada sauce, and lots of toppings. They are perfect for a quick and easy weeknight meal.
Get the Recipe: Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes

Mojo Salmon Bowls

Mojo Salmon Bowls with all the toppings and dressing ready to be enjoyed.
Photo credit: Chelsea’s Messy Apron

These Mojo Salmon Bowls are a flavor explosion! Cuban-inspired and packed with fresh ingredients like salmon, black beans, pineapple, and avocado, all drizzled with a killer sauce, they’re perfect for a healthy and delicious meal prep option.
Get the Recipe: Mojo Salmon Bowls

Sheet Pan Salmon with Potatoes and Chickpeas

sheet pan salmon with potatoes and chickpeas drizzled with yogurt sauce
Photo credit: Ambitious Kitchen

This Sheet Pan Salmon with Potatoes and Chickpeas recipe is perfect for a quick and healthy dinner. The salmon is cooked on a sheet pan with potatoes and crispy chickpeas, then topped with a flavorful herby yogurt sauce. It’s gluten-free, grain-free, and nut-free, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions.
Get the Recipe: Sheet Pan Salmon with Potatoes and Chickpeas

Baked French Toast

Baked french toast on a plate covered with berries.
Photo credit: Culinary Hill

This Baked French Toast recipe is perfect for a make-ahead breakfast or brunch. Prepare it the night before and top with a delicious cinnamon streusel and fresh blueberries before baking. This recipe serves six and is sure to be a crowd-pleaser!
Get the Recipe: Baked French Toast

Slow Cooker Green Bean Casserole

A plate of green bean casserole.
Photo credit: Culinary Hill

Free up oven space this holiday season with this convenient yet delicious Slow Cooker Green Bean Casserole. This recipe combines the ease of a slow cooker with the comforting flavors of a made-from-scratch casserole, featuring fresh mushrooms, garlic, and green beans. Top with crispy fried onions for the perfect finishing touch.
Get the Recipe: Slow Cooker Green Bean Casserole

Sheet Pan Moroccan-Spiced Chicken with Sweet Potatoes & Cauliflower

sheet pan moroccan chicken and veggies on a plate next to yogurt sauce
Photo credit: Ambitious Kitchen

This easy sheet pan Moroccan chicken recipe with sweet potatoes and cauliflower is a healthy and flavorful dinner option! The chicken and veggies are tossed in a delicious blend of Moroccan spices and roasted to perfection. Garnish with dried cherries, cilantro, and pistachios for an extra pop of flavor.
Get the Recipe: Sheet Pan Moroccan-Spiced Chicken with Sweet Potatoes & Cauliflower

Healthy Chocolate Chip Sweet Potato Muffins

sweet potato muffin topped with peanut butter
Photo credit: Ambitious Kitchen

These Healthy Chocolate Chip Sweet Potato Muffins are fluffy, flavorful, and perfect for breakfast or a snack. Packed with sweet potato and chocolate chips, they’re also freezer-friendly for meal prep! These muffins are sure to be a hit with both kids and adults.
Get the Recipe: Healthy Chocolate Chip Sweet Potato Muffins

Greek Slow Cooker Lemon Chicken and Potatoes

Greek Lemon Chicken and Potatoes on a plate with asparagus
Photo credit: Cooking Classy

This Greek Slow Cooker Lemon Chicken and Potatoes recipe is perfect for busy weeknights! Bone-in chicken thighs are slow-cooked with potatoes, lemon juice, and herbs for a tender and flavorful meal. Simply toss everything in the slow cooker and come home to a delicious dinner.
Get the Recipe: Greek Slow Cooker Lemon Chicken and Potatoes

Fully Loaded Potato Skins with Chipotle Southwest Guacamole

Fully Loaded Potato Skins with Chipotle Southwest | halfbakedharvest.com @hbharvest
Photo credit: Half Baked Harvest

Looking for the perfect game day appetizer? These Fully Loaded Potato Skins with Chipotle Southwest Guacamole are sure to be a crowd-pleaser. Crispy potato skins are topped with all the fixings and a flavorful guacamole for a delicious and satisfying snack.
Get the Recipe: Fully Loaded Potato Skins with Chipotle Southwest Guacamole

Coconut Banana Cake with Chocolate Frosting

A slice of layered cake with chocolate frosting sits on a ceramic plate. A fork rests beside the cake, and a small purple flower is placed near it.
Photo credit: Half Baked Harvest

This Coconut Banana Cake with Chocolate Frosting recipe by Half Baked Harvest uses roasted bananas, which truly elevates the flavor. If you love bananas, coconut, and chocolate, you absolutely have to make this cake!
Get the Recipe: Coconut Banana Cake with Chocolate Frosting

Beef and Noodles

beef and noodles in a bowl
Photo credit: Spend with Pennies

This hearty beef and noodles recipe is comfort food at its finest! Tender beef is slow-cooked in a rich, savory gravy, creating a deeply satisfying meal. Serve it over egg noodles or mashed potatoes for a classic and comforting dinner.
Get the Recipe: Beef and Noodles

Herbed Cheddar Latkes

overhead photo of Herbed Cheddar Latkes with latke broken in half
Photo credit: Half Baked Harvest

These Herbed Cheddar Latkes are a fun and flavorful twist on the traditional potato pancake! Shredded potatoes, sharp cheddar cheese, and fresh herbs combine to create a crispy and addictive appetizer or side dish. Serve them with Greek yogurt or applesauce for the perfect bite.
Get the Recipe: Herbed Cheddar Latkes

Want to save this recipe?
Just enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! Plus you'll get new recipes from us every week!

About Jenny deRemer

I am a Charleston, South Carolina-based culinary novice, an ardent authority on all things travel, a designer by trade, and the creator of Not Entirely Average. I have a weakness for farmers' markets, delight in adventures way off the beaten path, enjoy documenting my many moods through photography, and have been known to conquer the occasional yard sale with gusto!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *