Sandwiches That Would Make Dagwood Proud

Jenny deRemer

Aug 07, 2025

This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy + disclosures for details.

Remember Dagwood, the comic strip hero known for crafting towering, irresistible sandwiches in the wee hours? Inspired by his nocturnal culinary adventures, this slideshow is a tribute to all things sandwich. From classic combinations to new creations, we’ll show you how to elevate your sandwich game. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or an epic midnight feast, these recipes are sure to satisfy your cravings and maybe even inspire your own midnight sandwich run!

Table of Contents

Pressed Italian Picnic Sandwiches

ie-canva_free__studio_philippines-chapati_flour-2655979
Image Credit: xoxoBella.

Pressed Italian Picnic Sandwiches go beyond just picnic fare. While they are perfect for summer outings due to their travel-friendly nature, they also make a fantastic lunch option when you’re craving a genuine Italian flavor experience. Prepare these sandwiches and delight in the incredible array of flavors with each bite, bringing a taste of Italy right to your plate. Whether at a picnic or at your dining table, these sandwiches are sure to impress.

GET THE RECIPE: PRESSED ITALIAN PICNIC SANDWICHES

Pizza Grilled Cheese

A toasted sandwich stuffed with melty cheese and pepperoni slices.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Elevate your weekend lunch or snack with a Pizza Grilled Cheese, combining delicious pizza toppings with a crispy grilled cheese sandwich. This irresistible combination will have you craving more!

GET THE RECIPE: PIZZA GRILLED CHEESE

Grilled Peach, Brie & Basil Sandwich

A grilled cheese sandwich with melted cheese, peach slices, and basil leaves is cut in half and placed on a wooden plate. Fresh peaches and a jar of honey are in the background, along with a green plant in a glass vase.
Image Credit: Two Peas and Their Pod.

Grilled Peach, Brie & Basil Sandwich takes simplicity to a gourmet level with its combination of warm, grilled peaches and creamy Brie cheese, complemented by fresh basil leaves. The ensemble is sweetened with a drizzle of honey, enhancing the natural flavors and adding a delightful sweetness. This sandwich offers a unique blend of textures and tastes, making it a perfect choice for those seeking a sophisticated yet easy meal.

GET THE RECIPE: GRILLED PEACH, BRIE & BASIL SANDWICH

Vegan Cucumber Sandwich

Hands holding a halved sandwich filled with cucumber and greens.
Image Credit: Erika Piper for The Veggie Yaya.

This straightforward classic checks all the sandwich boxes: freshness, crunch, and simplicity. Crisp cucumber slices seasoned with salt and pepper, layered on fluffy buttered bread, topped with peppery arugula.

GET THE RECIPE: VEGAN CUCUMBER SANDWICH

The Original Monte Cristo Sandwich

A plated meal featuring a Monte Cristo sandwich, halved and arranged around a small glass of red jam. Garnished with powdered sugar and surrounded by fresh grapes and melon slices, the sandwich displays layers of ham and turkey between thick slices of bread.
Image Credit: Not Entirely Average.

The Original Monte Cristo Sandwich has long been a culinary marvel, enchanting diners with its crisp, melty allure. Constructed majestically like Cinderella’s castle, this sandwich features layers of two rich cheeses, delicious ham, and turkey, all dipped in batter and fried to create a molten core. The result is nothing short of epic—a truly sigh-worthy dish that embodies the ultimate in comfort food indulgence.

GET THE RECIPE: THE ORIGINAL MONTE CRISTO SANDWICH

Vegetable Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Two stacked toasted sandwiches with cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Take the classic grilled cheese sandwich to the next level by stuffing it with fried onions and mushrooms, crispy lettuce, and juicy tomato. This delicious twist makes for an exceptional diner style breakfast or lunch.

GET THE RECIPE: VEGETABLE GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH

Spinach And Feta Grilled Cheese

A halved stacked toasted sandwich filled with cheese and spinach.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Elevate your grilled cheese with this gourmet twist featuring fresh spinach and tangy feta cheese in a tribute to Greek spanakopita. This crispy, melty masterpiece is perfect for a quick lunch, or effortless dinner.

GET THE RECIPE: SPINACH AND FETA GRILLED CHEESE

Havarti Cranberry Turkey Sliders

A close-up of a wooden board holding a batch of cranberry turkey sliders. The sliders are made with soft, golden dinner rolls filled with slices of turkey, cranberry sauce, and melted cheese. Poppy seeds are sprinkled on top. Some plates and drinks are in the background.
Image Credit: Noshing with The Nolands.

These Havarti Cranberry Turkey Sliders are perfect for lunch or as a game-day treat! Packed with fresh ingredients like creamy Havarti cheese, tangy cranberry sauce, and tender turkey, these sliders are topped off with a delightful poppy seed butter sauce. Once baked, they turn into a melty, cheesy delight!

GET THE RECIPE: HAVARTI CRANBERRY TURKEY SLIDERS

Vegan Coronation Chicken Sandwich

A stacked halved sandwich with a yellow jackfruit filling.
Image Credit: Erika Piper for The Veggie Yaya.

This curry jackfruit sandwich filling features jackfruit seasoned with curry powder, cinnamon, mango chutney, raisins and chives, all layered between two sliced of buttered bread. It’s a unique yet comforting combination, perfect for taking care of your vegan friends.

GET THE RECIPE: VEGAN CORONATION CHICKEN SANDWICH

Cheese Croissant Sandwich

A croissant on a plate stuffed with lettuce, cheese, and pickled red onions.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

These air fried croissant sandwiches are crispy, cheesy, and effortlessly prepared. Flaky croissants become golden and crispy, while Havarti cheese melts into gooey goodness in just 4 minutes.

GET THE RECIPE: CHEESE CROISSANT SANDWICH

Steak Po Boy

Three sub buns on a baking tray, stuffed with meat and veggies.
Image Credit: Jenny DeRemer for Not Entirely Average

Indulge in this flavourful po’ boy steak sandwich, made with marinated and grilled steak, and a buttery hoagie bun, topped with a simple combination of mayo and crisp lettuce.

GET THE RECIPE: STEAK PO BOY

Pumpernickel Sandwich

A halved stacked sandwich on dark brown pumpernickel bread filled with a white sauce and cucumber slices.
Image Credit: Erika Piper for The Veggie Yaya.

Dark, subtly sweet pumpernickel bread slathered with a homemade garlic and dill cream cheese, topped with crisp cucumber slices. This simple yet tasty pairing makes for an ideal quick lunch.

GET THE RECIPE: PUMPERNICKEL SANDWICH

Kings Hawaiian Ham and Cheese Sliders

A closeup of small buns topped with onions and filled with meat and greens.
Image Credit: Jenny DeRemer for Not Entirely Average

Why make 1 sandwich at a time when you can make 52? These King’s Hawaiian rolls are stuffed with thinly sliced deli ham and gooey Swiss cheese, smothered in a tangy double mustard and Vidalia onion sauce. Delish!

GET THE RECIPE: KINGS HAWAIIAN HAM AND CHEESE SLIDERS

Grilled Cheese in An Air Fryer

A stacked halved toasted sandwich filled with melty white cheese.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Whip up air-fryer grilled cheese sandwiches with sourdough bread and Havarti cheese in just 5 minutes! Perfect for a quick work-at-home lunch or a fast dinner on busy nights.

GET THE RECIPE: GRILLED CHEESE IN AN AIR FRYER

Easy French Dip Sandwiches with Picante Provolone

A close-up of a roast beef sandwich with caramelized onions and cheese in a bun, partially dipped in a bowl of brown gravy. French fries and a salt shaker are visible in the background.
Image Credit: Not Entirely Average.

Every bite of this Easy French Dip Sandwich, loaded with tender, fall-apart beef and overstuffed with picante Provolone, invites you into a world of comfort. Dunked in a rich, creamy au jus, this sandwich is sure to become one of your go-to favorites for its satisfying flavors and comforting warmth.

GET THE RECIPE: EASY FRENCH DIPS WITH PICANTE PROVOLONE

Chickpea Avocado Sandwich

Two stacked sub buns filled with smashed chickpeas, spinach, and cucumber slices.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Make your lunch more satisfying with this chickpea avocado salad sandwich spread. This creamy blend of smashed chickpeas, avocado, green onions, and fresh herbs pairs perfectly with your favourite bread or bun.

GET THE RECIPE: CHICKPEA AVOCADO SANDWICH

Leftover Beef Tenderloin Sandwiches

A close-up of two sandwiches filled with sliced roast beef, red bell peppers, and melted cheese, served on a rectangular white plate. Three black-handled knives are placed beside the sandwiches, and a small bowl of au jus dipping sauce is on the side.
Image Credit: Not Entirely Average.

Leftover Beef Tenderloin Sandwiches turn already tender slices of flavorful filet mignon roast into a sublime meal with minimal additions. The remnants of a luxurious beef tenderloin roast are just as splendid when thinly sliced and generously stacked on fresh, toasty rolls. Elevate these with layers of room-temperature roasted peppers and a dollop of sour cream horseradish sauce, then finish with a warm beef broth au jus for a true showcase of culinary brilliance.

GET THE RECIPE: LEFTOVER BEEF TENDERLOIN SANDWICHES

New York Club Sandwich

A sliced sandwich in a bowl with chips, filled with meat, cheese, tomato, and lettuce.
Image Credit: Jenny DeRemer for Not Entirely Average

Similar to the classic BLT sandwich, this New York club sandwich features an array of cheeses, deli chicken or turkey, bacon, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and mayonnaise.

GET THE RECIPE: NEW YORK CLUB SANDWICH

Rainbow Vegetable Sandwich

A hand with pink nails holds a colorful vegetable sandwich made with whole grain bread. The sandwich is filled with layers of purple cabbage, tomato slices, shredded carrots, avocado, yellow bell pepper, and assorted greens.
Image Credit: Two Peas and Their Pod.

Rainbow Vegetable Sandwich—this vibrant and nutritious sandwich is a feast for the eyes as well as the palate, beautifully layered with a spectrum of colorful vegetables. Each bite offers a crisp and fresh taste, making it not only a healthy choice but a deliciously satisfying one. Perfect for anyone looking to add more veggies to their diet in a delightful and easy way!

GET THE RECIPE: RAINBOW VEGETABLE SANDWICH

Caprese Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Closeup of a halved stacked toasted sandwich filed with melty cheese, tomato slices, and basil.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Enjoy a classic grilled cheese sandwich with a twist. Stringy, melty mozzarella cheese, fresh tomatoes, and fragrant basil leaves. It’s a fun and delicious take on a lunchtime staple.

GET THE RECIPE: CAPRESE GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH

Gourmet Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Turkey, Apple, and Fig Jam

Close-up of a stacked sandwich with melted cheese, apple slices, sliced turkey, leafy greens, and multigrain bread on a wooden surface against a black background.
Image Credit: Not Entirely Average.

Discover the pinnacle of gourmet melts with this Grilled Cheese Sandwich, which artfully combines smoked Gouda, lean turkey, crisp apple slices, and rich fig jam. This sandwich is a culinary touchdown, perfect for a game day treat or a luxurious midday meal. Every bite offers a harmonious blend of smoky, sweet, and savory flavors, making it a standout choice for any occasion.

GET THE RECIPE: GOURMET GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH WITH TURKEY, APPLE, AND FIG JAM

Peanut Butter Cucumber Sandwich

A stacked halved sandwich filled with peanut butter and cucumber slices.
Image Credit: Erika Piper for The Veggie Yaya.

Once you try this combo, you’ll never look back! This simple but refreshing peanut butter and cucumber sandwich is incredibly easy to prepare and makes an ideal quick snack or lunch.

GET THE RECIPE: PEANUT BUTTER CUCUMBER SANDWICH

Caprese Sandwich

ie-canva_free__studio_philippines-chapati_flour-2655979
Image Credit: Culinary Hill.

This Caprese Sandwich recipe delivers a dreamy summer lunch in just 10 minutes. Ideal for potlucks and picnics, it pairs fresh basil leaves with a basil pesto aioli that perfectly complements the flavors. This combination creates one of the most delightful summer sandwiches you’ll ever taste, embodying the freshness and vibrancy of the season in every bite.

GET THE RECIPE: CAPRESE SANDWICH

Turkey Pesto Sandwich

A sandwich on focaccia with green pesto, turkey sliced, tomato sliced, and lettuce leaves.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Whip up these incredibly easy turkey pesto sandwiches on fluffy focaccia bread. Layer on a creamy pesto mayo sauce, spicy cheese, crisp romaine lettuce, roasted turkey breast slices, and tomatoes for a delicious meal.

GET THE RECIPE: TURKEY PESTO SANDWICH

Steak Sandwich

Close-up of a steak sandwich with arugula, roasted red peppers, and crusty bread. Some fries are partially visible in the background.
Image Credit: Two Peas and Their Pod.

Steak Sandwich—succulent steak, sautéed peppers and onions, melted provolone cheese, vibrant chimichurri, and peppery arugula heaped on toasted bread. This sandwich is simple to prepare yet delivers a gourmet taste! Pair it with fries, chips, veggies, or a salad for a complete meal.

GET THE RECIPE: STEAK SANDWICH

Fried Oyster Mushroom Sandwich

Two sub buns filled with crispy fried mushrooms, pickled, tomato slices, lettuce, and a white sauce.
Image Credit: Jacqueline Piper for PiperCooks

Soft French bread topped with crispy fried oyster mushrooms, fresh lettuce, juicy pickles, and tomatoes. Topped off with a tangy, creamy remoulade-style sauce for a satisfying sandwich.

GET THE RECIPE: FRIED OYSTER MUSHROOM SANDWICH

Want to save this recipe?
Just enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! Plus you'll get new recipes from us every week!

Categorized as:

About Jenny deRemer

I am a Charleston, South Carolina-based culinary novice, an ardent authority on all things travel, a designer by trade, and the creator of Not Entirely Average. I have a weakness for farmers' markets, delight in adventures way off the beaten path, enjoy documenting my many moods through photography, and have been known to conquer the occasional yard sale with gusto!

Read More About Me

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *