The Only Super Bowl Menu You’ll Ever Need (Seriously, We Nailed It)

This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy + disclosures for details.

Alright, folks, if you want your Super Bowl Sunday to go down in history (or at least be remembered for more than just the game), these meatier, heartier recipes are your ticket to greatness. We’re talking Cast Iron Cheddar Bacon Beer Brats that will have your guests singing your praises, and a Sweet, Sticky, Spicy Bourbon Glaze that’ll make those wings the talk of the tailgate. Want to take it up a notch? How To Make the Best Damn Wagyu Meatloaf will have everyone asking for seconds—and maybe even the recipe. For the nacho lovers, Southern Pimento Cheese Nachos are here to change your life. And let’s not forget dessert—those Peanut Butter Brownies and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies? Yeah, they’ll disappear faster than a touchdown. Get ready to make your watch party legendary, because with these recipes, you’ll be on the map for sure!

Crispy Southern Buttermilk Onion Rings

Want to save this recipe?
Just enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! Plus you’ll get new recipes from us every week!
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
A pile of crispy, golden brown onion rings on parchment paper next to a small bowl of red ketchup on a wooden surface.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average

These Crispy Southern Buttermilk Onion Rings are the snack you didn’t know you needed for game day. Crunchy, golden, and soaked in that buttermilk goodness, they’re perfect on burgers or just as a snack that’s too good to share. Seriously, no tailgate is complete without these crispy bites of magic!
Get the Recipe: Crispy Southern Buttermilk Onion Rings

A Sweet, Sticky, Spicy Bourbon Glaze

A spoon drizzles a thick, brown sauce with visible spices back into a metal pot.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average

Sweet, Sticky, Spicy Bourbon Glaze isn’t just a sauce—it’s a game-changer. With its bold mix of sweet, smoky, and spicy flavors, this glaze turns grilled meats, seafood, and even veggies into something worth bragging about. One brush of this magic, and suddenly, you’re the pitmaster everyone wants to know.

Get the Recipe: A Sweet, Sticky, Spicy Bourbon Glaze

Cast Iron Cheddar Bacon Beer Brats

Five hot dogs topped with yellow mustard, chopped onions, and fresh cilantro are arranged on a platter. The buns are slightly toasted, and the hot dogs are nestled in the buns with even toppings.
Photo credit: Dutch Oven Daddy

If you’ve ever stood in the grocery store eyeing the endless lineup of sausages, you already know brats are a solid choice—but this method takes them to the next level. Juicy, flavorful, and ridiculously easy to scale up, Cast Iron Cheddar Bacon Beer Brats are made for Super Bowl-sized appetites. Double or triple the batch EASILY!

Get the Recipe: Cast Iron Cheddar Bacon Beer Brats

Citrus Shrimp with Louis Sauce

A ramekin with sauce and shrimp around it.
Image Credit: Jenny DeRemer for Not Entirely Average

If shrimp cocktail is on your list of big game grub to serve, it’s time to acknowledge the city hosting the teams and. New Orleans-Style Louis Sauce isn’t just cocktail sauce with horseradish—it’s a bold, savory upgrade palate-pleaser. Odds are, your pantry’s already stocked with everything but the lemon, so there’s no excuse not to give this a go!

Get the Recipe: Citrus Shrimp with Louis Sauce

How To Make the Best Damn Wagyu Meatloaf

A meatloaf sliced on a wooden platter next to a bowl of sautéed green vegetables. A colorful striped cloth is placed in the background.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average.

Wagyu Meatloaf is the MVP of any Super Bowl groaning board, bringing rich, buttery beef flavor to the table with minimal effort. This two-pound masterpiece is really magic in both hot and cold meatloaf sandwiches. Whether it’s fueling game day or feeding the post-game crew, this is a ‘one for the books’ meatloaf done right.

Get the Recipe: How to Make the Best Damn Wagyu Meatloaf

Southern Pimento Cheese Nachos

A skillet piled high with pimento cheese nachos.
Image Credit: Not Entirely Average

Southern Pimento Cheese Nachos take classic nachos and crank up the comfort. Creamy, tangy pimento cheese blankets every chip, while sweet gem peppers and spicy chorizo bring the perfect balance of heat and sweetness. Whether you’re making a party-sized platter or a solo snack, these nachos are dangerously easy to devour!

Get the Recipe: Southern Pimento Cheese Nachos

Tailgater Frito Pie with Cowgirl Chili

Fritos corn chips smothered in chili with jalapeños and chopped tomatoes.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average

Tailgater Frito Pie with Cowgirl Chili turns snack-time chips into party-time magic. Loaded with hearty chili con carne, it’s a hit with kids and adults alike. Easily scaled up for a crowd, this dish is your go-to for tailgates and gatherings!

Get the Recipe: Frito Pie

Herb and Cheese Puff Pastry Appetizers

Close-up of a decorative plate with savory pinwheel pastries topped with melted cheese and green onions. The pastries have a golden-brown crust, and the plate features an intricate green floral pattern on the rim. A striped cloth is partially visible.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average

Herb and Cheese Puff Pastry Appetizers are as easy to make as they are delicious! These golden, flaky bites are filled with rich Boursin cheese, sharp cheddar, and Parmesan, with fresh herbs tossed in for extra flair. Perfect for a happy hour snack that’ll have everyone reaching for seconds!
Get the Recipe: Herb and Cheese Puff Pastry Appetizers

Creamy Whipped Feta Dip with Garlic and Toasted Walnuts

A bowl of creamy dip drizzled with olive oil and sprinkled with chopped herbs and crushed nuts, placed on a rustic wooden table with a green distressed finish.
Photo credit: Not Entirely Average

Effortless appetizers like this Whipped Feta Dip are game day MVPs. Creamy, tangy, and garlicky enough to make a statement, it’s perfect for crostini, fresh veggies, or even toasted walnuts. Serve this dip, and watch it become the snack table star!
Get the Recipe: Creamy Whipped Feta Dip with Garlic and Toasted Walnuts

Peanut Butter Brownies

A skillet with a freshly baked brownie topped with peanut butter cups rests on a wooden surface. A white and green striped cloth is nearby, along with a stack of white plates on the side.
Photo credit: Dutch Oven Daddy

Peanut Butter Brownies are the ultimate game day treat—because football and chocolate just belong together. Packed with peanut butter cups and baked into fudgy perfection, these easy brownies bring the best of chocolate and peanut butter in every bite. Whether you’re cheering or stress-eating, this dessert is a winner no matter the score!
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Brownies

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

Seven oatmeal cookies with chocolate chips are arranged in a black skillet on a dark wooden surface. The cookies have a golden-brown hue and a rustic texture, filling the pan with a homemade appearance.
Photo credit: Dutch Oven Daddy

When it comes to football desserts, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies are the perfect grab-and-go option. Chewy, chocolatey, and made for snacking, they’re just right for halftime munching or a post-game sugar boost. No forks—just classic cookie goodness that keeps the crowd happy!
Get the Recipe: Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

Caramel Apple Dump Cake

A baked dessert in a cast iron skillet contains a crumbly topping, scoops of vanilla ice cream, and caramel drizzle. Sliced apples and mint leaves garnish the dish. The skillet is placed on a rustic wooden surface.
Photo credit: Dutch Oven Daddy

Caramel Apple Dump Cake is the ultimate hands-off football dessert—just dump everything in one pot, let it bake, and move on to the rest of your game day feast. Warm, spiced apples and moist cake come together for a cozy, crowd-pleasing treat, while a drizzle of caramel takes it straight into the end zone. Set out some spoons and let everyone dig in straight from the Dutch oven—because the less cleanup, the better!
Get the Recipe: Caramel Apple Dump Cake

About Jenny deRemer

I am a Charleston, South Carolina-based culinary novice, an ardent authority on all things travel, a designer by trade, and the creator of Not Entirely Average. I have a weakness for farmers' markets, delight in adventures way off the beaten path, enjoy documenting my many moods through photography, and have been known to conquer the occasional yard sale with gusto!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *